EA comparison guideCompare forex EAs with a repeatable buying framework
Use a twelve-point forex EA comparison covering risk, execution, evidence, trials and licensing. Record what each product documents and what you test.
What to expect
Separate product facts from vendor claims. Compare market/timeframe, trading frequency, risk sizing, stop behavior, recovery methods, execution costs, backtest construction, live evidence, licensing, support, updates and trial access.
What you can verify
For Smooth Operator FX, the site publishes dated MT5 Strategy Tester results and states they are simulations. Preserve the same distinction when comparing any competing EA.
Record the same twelve points for every EA
EA comparison worksheet| Check | What to record |
|---|
| 1. Platform and market | Terminal version, operating system, supported symbols and timeframe. |
|---|
| 2. Trading behavior | Entry/exit approach, historical trade count and periods with little or no activity. |
|---|
| 3. Position sizing and stop | Sizing reference, initial stop, planned-risk limits and how fills can differ. |
|---|
| 4. Daily and account-wide loss | Reset time, floating P/L treatment and exposure from other positions. |
|---|
| 5. Loss recovery | Lot-size changes after losses, averaging, grids and simultaneous exposure. |
|---|
| 6. Execution costs | Spread, commission, slippage, swap and whether the report already includes them. |
|---|
| 7. Backtest construction | Test window, broker/data source, settings, cost assumptions and disabled controls. |
|---|
| 8. Evidence type | Historical simulation, demo observation or verified live performance; keep them separate. |
|---|
| 9. Trial scope | When the clock starts, allowed accounts and which functions can be observed. |
|---|
| 10. License | Payment schedule, activations, renewal, cancellation and permitted use. |
|---|
| 11. Updates and support | Included period, delivery process and the route for obtaining help. |
|---|
| 12. Ongoing operation | Terminal uptime, news-feed health, notifications and a process for reviewing failures. |
|---|
Use “not documented” or “not observed” when information is missing. Do not fill gaps with an assumed benefit. Smooth Operator FX provides historical MT5 simulations, a protected demo and public setup and risk documentation for this comparison.